Central Government tells Supreme Court creamy layer does not apply to SC/ST reservation
The Indian government has informed the Supreme Court that the creamy layer principle, which excludes economically advanced individuals from reservation benefits, cannot be applied to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. In an affidavit, the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment argued that reservation for these groups is based on historical and social criteria rather than economic status alone. The government urged the court to dismiss petitions seeking to introduce income-based exclusions for these communities, asserting that only Parliament has the authority to amend the lists of eligible populations.
6 paksh
What Happened
The Union government filed an affidavit in the Supreme Court opposing the introduction of a creamy layer concept for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. The government stated that the existing legal framework limits the application of the creamy layer principle to Other Backward Classes and Socially and Educationally Backward Classes. It argued that the challenges faced by SC and ST communities are rooted in historical and social factors that transcend economic status, making income-based exclusion inappropriate for these groups.
The government further maintained that the petitions seeking to restrict reservation benefits for affluent SC and ST families should be dismissed. It emphasized that any changes to the classification of these groups fall under the exclusive jurisdiction of Parliament. This position comes in response to legal challenges that sought to ensure reservation benefits reach the most economically disadvantaged members within these communities.
Key Facts
- The central government filed an affidavit in the Supreme Court regarding SC/ST reservation.
- The government stated the creamy layer principle is not applicable to SC/ST categories.
- The government argued that SC/ST reservation is based on historical and social criteria.
- The government asserted that only Parliament has the power to amend SC/ST lists.
- The government requested the dismissal of petitions seeking to apply the creamy layer to SC/ST groups.
The Timeline6
Every article on this story, in the order it was filed. We do not rank the outlets.
6 Aug
7 Aug
- TOIThe Times of IndiaCan't exclude SC/ST creamy layer from quotas: Government to Supreme Court
Show all 6 articlesShow fewer
Where This Is Being Covered4 languages
Languages
Newsrooms carrying this story, by publication language.
- English2 outlets
- Hindiहिन्दी2 outlets
- Tamilதமிழ்1 outlet
- Malayalamമലയാളം1 outlet
Regional reach
States where a local newsroom is carrying this. National mastheads and wire agencies circulate everywhere and are counted separately, not drawn on the map.
- No local newsroom
- 1 outlet
- 2 or more
15 states with local coverage. Spread across the country, with no regional concentration. Also carried by 2 national mastheads.
About This Analysis
One summary, built from every source. No single newsroom's voice.
- 6
- Paksh
- 6
- Articles
- 5
- Key facts
Paksh: the sides a story is told from. 6 newsrooms filed on this one, and every filing is listed above.