Kangana Ranaut and Naseeruddin Shah exchange criticisms over Bollywood silence
BJP MP and actor Kangana Ranaut has publicly criticised veteran actor Naseeruddin Shah after he accused Bollywood celebrities of remaining silent on student protests. Shah had compared the industry's silence to dogs that only bark when they are not occupied with a bone. Ranaut responded by calling Shah a fox and questioning his stance on ongoing protests in Jharkhand, while also referencing past incidents of unrest. The exchange has drawn further commentary from actor Piyush Mishra, who questioned the motivations behind Shah's remarks.
4 paksh
What Happened
BJP MP and actor Kangana Ranaut recently engaged in a public dispute with veteran actor Naseeruddin Shah. The conflict began when Shah criticised Bollywood figures for their perceived silence regarding student protests, using a metaphor to suggest that celebrities only speak out when it serves their interests. In response, Ranaut labelled Shah a fox and questioned his silence on specific protests occurring in Jharkhand. She further defended her position by highlighting her own experiences with public unrest and criticising the industry's historical attitude toward such issues.
The exchange has prompted additional reactions from within the film industry, including actor Piyush Mishra, who questioned the intent behind Shah's original comments. The dispute reflects broader tensions regarding the role of public figures in addressing social and political movements. Ranaut has also linked the current discourse to her broader criticisms of the film industry's political leanings and its relationship with Pakistan.
Key Facts
- Naseeruddin Shah criticised Bollywood celebrities for remaining silent on student protests.
- Shah used a metaphor comparing silent celebrities to dogs with bones in their mouths.
- Kangana Ranaut responded by calling Naseeruddin Shah a fox.
- Ranaut questioned why Shah has not spoken about student protests in Jharkhand.
- Actor Piyush Mishra also commented on the situation, questioning Shah's remarks.
- Ranaut is a sitting BJP Member of Parliament.
The Timeline4
Every article on this story, in the order it was filed. We do not rank the outlets.
12 Aug
- Nanamasthe-telanganaKangana Ranaut: నషీరుద్దీన్ షా ఓ నక్క.. బీజేపీ ఎంపీ కంగనా రనౌత్ కౌంటర్
13 Aug
- HTThindu-tamilநடிகர் நசிருதீன் ஷாவுக்கு கங்கனா ரனாவத் பதிலடி
- TOIThe Times of India'Pakistan ke prem mein mare rehte hai,' Kangana defends calling Naseeruddin fox
Where This Is Being Covered3 languages
Languages
Newsrooms carrying this story, by publication language.
- English2 outlets
- Teluguతెలుగు1 outlet
- Tamilதமிழ்1 outlet
Regional reach
States where a local newsroom is carrying this. National mastheads and wire agencies circulate everywhere and are counted separately, not drawn on the map.
- No local newsroom
- 1 outlet
- 2 or more
4 states with local coverage. Concentrated in the South. Also carried by 1 national masthead.
About This Analysis
One summary, built from every source. No single newsroom's voice.
- 4
- Paksh
- 3
- Articles
- 6
- Key facts
Paksh: the sides a story is told from. 4 newsrooms filed on this one, and every filing is listed above.